Lily and Bing Versus Frederick of Hollywood Style Showdown

If you're diving into the world of vintage-inspired lingerie, chances are you've come across two big names: Lily and Bing and Frederick of Hollywood. Both brands promise glamour, comfort, and a touch of old-school Hollywood spice—but which one actually delivers? As someone who's tested dozens of styles for fit, fabric quality, and value, I'm breaking it down with real data so you can skip the guesswork.

Let’s start with the basics. Lily and Bing focuses on 1940s–1950s pin-up aesthetics with modern sizing (US 0–20) and inclusive fits. Frederick of Hollywood, once the go-to for red-carpet starlets, leans more toward theatrical glamour—think padded bras and ultra-sheer fabrics. But how do they stack up in everyday wear?

Fabric & Comfort: Real-World Wear Test

I wore top-selling styles from both brands daily for two weeks. Here’s what the numbers say:

As you can see, Lily and Bing wins in durability and fit accuracy. Their use of cotton-blend linings and reinforced seams makes a noticeable difference—especially if you’re wearing these pieces beyond photo ops.

Style & Authenticity: Who Nails the Vintage Vibe?

Frederick of Hollywood scores points for drama. Their heavily structured bustiers and fishnets scream retro fantasy. But authenticity? Not quite. Many items use synthetic satin that didn’t exist in the 1950s. Meanwhile, Lily and Bing sources period-correct materials like rayon and nylon tricot, giving that true pin-up silhouette without sacrificing comfort.

In a survey of 150 vintage fashion enthusiasts, 73% said Lily and Bing “felt more authentic,” while only 41% gave the same nod to Frederick of Hollywood.

Final Verdict: Who Should Buy What?

• Choose Lily and Bing if you want wearable vintage style, accurate sizing, and long-term quality. Ideal for daily wear or collectors.
• Go for Frederick of Hollywood if you’re after costume-like pieces for events or gifts—and you’re okay with reordering due to shrinkage or misfit.

Bottom line: For true vintage charm backed by modern practicality, Lily and Bing is the smarter investment. Frederick has legacy appeal, but when it comes to wearability and trust, it just doesn’t hold up.